Commentary on Political Economy

Tuesday 8 September 2020



Australia revokes Chinese scholar visas and targets media officials, prompting furious China response

A graphic of four photos of Chinese individuals, including three men and one woman.
Chinese scholars Li Jianjun (top left) and Chen Hong (top right) and media officials Li Dayong (bottom left) and Tao Shelan (bottom right).(Supplied)

Senior Chinese media officials in Australia have been targeted and the visas of two leading Chinese scholars have been revoked in an unprecedented foreign interference investigation into a NSW political staffer, provoking a furious response from the Chinese Government.

Key points:

    The Chinese Government has sensationally used state media to accuse Australian authorities of secretly raiding the homes of four Chinese journalists in Australia in late June, after receiving questions from the ABC yesterday about the investigation.

    The Chinese embassy did not reply to the ABC's questions yesterday, but several state media organisations published articles overnight reporting details of the alleged raids and accusing Australia of "severely infring[ing] on the legitimate rights of Chinese journalists" and "hypocrisy in upholding so-called 'freedom of the press'".

    The ABC has uncovered the identities of senior Chinese journalists and academics who have been drawn into the joint investigation by the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO).

    They include: the Australia bureau chief of China News Service, Tao Shelan; China Radio International's Sydney bureau chief Li Dayong; prominent Chinese scholar and media commentator Professor Chen Hong; and another leading Australian studies scholar, Li Jianjun

    The AFP is investigating whether Mr Zhang used a chat group on the Chinese social media platform, WeChat, to encourage Mr Moselmane to advocate for the Chinese Government's interests.

    The journalists and academics have been drawn into the investigation over the alleged infiltration because they were members of the WeChat group.

    Mr Zhang categorically denies the AFP's allegations and is challenging the investigation in the High Court.

    According to documents filed by Mr Zhang in the High Court, the AFP alleges he and others "concealed or failed to disclose to Mr Moselmane that they were acting on behalf of or in collaboration with Chinese State and Party apparatus".

    Smith and Birtles with their arms around each others shoulders, as they stand in the middle of Shanghai Airport's terminal
    The Australian Financial Review's Michael Smith (left) and the ABC's Bill Birtles flew out of Shanghai on Monday night.(Supplied)

    The investigation has stoked an escalating diplomatic crisis between China and Australia, which has seen ABC correspondent Bill Birtles and Australian Financial Review journalist Michael Smith evacuated from China this week and a third Australian, TV news anchor Cheng Lei, detained last month and accused of endangering national security.

    The AFP-ASIO investigation became public in late June, when the task force raided NSW Parliament and searched the homes and offices of Mr Moselmane and Mr Zhang, seizing their devices and communications.

    China says Australian homes of media were raided

    Two men wearing black and carrying bags walk away from the gate of a house.
    Federal agents leave Shaoquett Moselmane's home in Sydney on June 26.(AAP: Bianca De Marchi)

    The Chinese journalists in Australia and their media organisations did not respond to questions sent by the ABC, however, China News Service last night reported that the homes of four journalists were searched on the day the other raids began.

    "At dawn of June 26 this year, Australian law enforcement officers conducted an unprovoked search on the residences of four journalists from three Chinese media organisations in Australia on the grounds of alleged violations of Australia's Foreign Influence Transparency Scheme Act," China News Service reported.

    "Items such as mobile phones, computers and writing materials were seized.

    "In the end, the Australian investigation results proved that the Chinese journalists did not engage in activities incompatible with their identities."

    The embassy has since provided a statement to the ABC, saying it has "provided consular support to Chinese journalists in Australia and made representations with relevant Australian authorities to safeguard legitimate rights and interests of Chinese citizens".

    The AFP and ASIO have declined to comment on the investigations.

    The China News Service is fully owned and overseen by the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office of China's State Council, which was merged into the Chinese Communist Party's foreign influence agency, the United Front Work Department, in 2018.

    Chinese scholars have visas revoked

    Two suited men sitting on chairs with graphic of building behind them
    In June 2018, Professor Chen interviewed Mr Moselmane in a filmed talk at the East China Normal University. Professor Chen criticised efforts by the Australian Government to criminalise foreign interference.(Supplied: East China Normal University)

    The ABC has also learned that the two Chinese scholars who were members of the WeChat group, Professor Chen and Mr Li, recently received letters from the Home Affairs Department, advising their Australian visas were being cancelled due to advice from ASIO of alleged risks to national security.

    Professor Chen is a regular visitor to Australia and commentator on Australian relations, featuring regularly in Australian media and writing in the Chinese state media tabloid, the Global Times.

    He declined the ABC's request for an interview but sent a statement, writing: "I was shocked to receive an email notifying me of visa cancellation on security grounds."

    Professor Chen told the ABC the WeChat group, nicknamed 'FD group' or 'Fair Dinkum group', was innocuous.

    "The group was a most ordinary social network platform on which members used to share jokes and funny memes, photos of personal excursions, fishing trips or drinks, and repost newspaper articles," he wrote.

    "The allegation that the group had been purported as a means of influence is simply preposterous.

    "Everything about the group is open to scrutiny.

    "The Australian authorities must have access to the content of the group. It is plain to any eye that nothing in the conversations and postings in that group has the remotest complicity of anything suspicious."

    Two men in office hold book called Australia's First Parliament with bookshelves in background
    Shaoquett Moselmane with Professor Chen at the Australian Studies Centre in the East China Normal University in 2016.(Supplied)

    He said his friendship with Mr Moselmane and Mr Zhang was "entirely aboveboard".

    Professor Chen is also a friend of former foreign minister and NSW premier Bob Carr, and was once the translator for former prime minister Bob Hawke on his 1994 trip to China.

    Professor Chen and Mr Li have built their careers in China with the help of grants from Australia's Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) and private companies, as part of its Australian Studies in China soft power program.

    Both Professor Chen and Mr Li run Australian studies centres at Shanghai's East China Normal University and the Beijing Foreign Studies University.

    Mr Li has been doing a PhD at the University of Western Sydney, funded by a $60,000 Australia China Scholarship from BHP Billiton as part of the program, however his student visa was also recently revoked.

    Zhang maintains innocence

    Two men wearing suits stand in busy street with many people behind them
    Shaoquett Moselmane and John Zhang at a street festival.(Facebook)

    Mr Zhang is challenging the investigation in the High Court, arguing Australia's new foreign interference legislation is unconstitutional because it breaches the implied freedom of political communication.

    He is also seeking to quash the warrants relied on by the AFP to search his home, office and NSW Parliament House.

    His application to the High Court, filed last month, states that the AFP search warrants accuse Mr Zhang and others, who are not named, of "acting on behalf of the 'Chinese State and Party apparatus' in a 'private social media chat group and other fora' with Mr Moselmane".

    The documents say the warrants allege Mr Zhang and others "advanced the interests and policy goals of a foreign principle, being the Chinese Government, in Australia by providing support and encouragement to Mr Moselmane for the advocacy of 'Chinese state interests'".

    According to the document, they are alleged to have "concealed from or failed to disclose to Mr Moselmane that they were acting on behalf of or in collaboration with Chinese State and Party apparatus including the Ministry of State Security and the United Front Work Department".

    The documents also say the AFP alleges that the group was "reckless … that the conduct would influence the NSW branch of the Australian Labor Party's policy positions and the views of members of the NSW electorate on China, and that part of the conduct was covert, in that it involved communications over a private social media chat group".

    A man wears a suit and tie.
    Labor backbencher Shaoquett Moselmane has rejected suggestions he would be the target of a foreign influence campaign.(ABC News: Jerry Rickard)

    In an interview with the 7.30 program last month, Mr Moselmane said he did not believe he was a suspect in the investigation.

    He rejected any suggestion he would be the target of a foreign influence campaign.

    When asked whether he discussed his speeches or parliamentary work over the chat, Mr Moselmane said: "Not necessarily … I mean, sometimes we share articles, or we share speech or share comment. We share jokes. This is a common human thing."

    No comments:

    Post a Comment